Purging with Nitrogen
Table of Contents
Before any maintenance or hot work (like welding) can begin on equipment containing hydrogen (\(\text{H}_2\)), the line must be proven safe. This is achieved by purging with an inert gas, typically nitrogen (\(\text{N}_2\)). This process involves replacing a dangerous gas with a safe one. The core question is: how much \(\text{N}_2\) is “enough”?
The Hazard: The Flammability Envelope #
The primary danger is the combination of \(\text{H}_2\) (fuel) and \(\text{O}_2\) (oxidizer, from air) with an ignition source (welding).
We must stay outside the flammability envelope. The key safety parameters are:
- \(\text{LEL}_{\text{H}_2}\): The Lower Explosive Limit. This is the minimum fuel concentration to ignite. \(\text{LEL}_{\text{H}_2} \approx 4.0\%\) (or \(40,000 \ \text{ppm}\))
- \(\text{UEL}_{\text{H}_2}\): The Upper Explosive Limit. \(\text{UEL}_{\text{H}_2} \approx 75.0\%\)
- \(\text{LOC}_{\text{O}_2}\): The Limiting Oxygen Concentration. This is the minimum \(\text{O}_2\) needed for a \(\text{H}_2\) fire.
$$\text{LOC}_{\text{H}_2} \approx 5.0\% \ \text{O}_2$$
For hot work, the line must be opened to air (which is \(\approx 21%\ \text{O}_2\)). Therefore, we must ensure the \(\text{H}_2\) concentration,
\(C_{\text{H}_2}\), is well below its LEL.
A standard industrial target is \(C_{\text{target}} < 10%\ \text{LEL}\).
$$ C_{\text{target}} < 0.10 \times \text{LEL}_{\text{H}_2} = 0.10 \times 4.0\% = 0.4\% \ \text{H}_2 $$
Our goal is to purge the line from \(C_i = 100%\ \text{H}_2\) (initial state) to \(C_f < 0.4%\ \text{H}_2\) (final state).
The Mathematics of Purging #
We must calculate the required purge volume, \(V_p\), as a multiple of the line’s internal volume, \(V_L\). This ratio is the number of volume changes, \(N\).
$$ N = \frac{V_p}{V_L} $$
We can model this purge using the conservative perfect mixing (CSTR) model. The final concentration \(C_f\) is an exponential decay of the initial concentration \(C_i\):
$$ C_f = C_i \cdot e^{-N} $$
To find the required number of volumes \(N\), we rearrange the formula: $$ \frac{C_f}{C_i} = e^{-N} $$ $$ N = -\ln\left(\frac{C_f}{C_i}\right) = \ln\left(\frac{C_i}{C_f}\right) $$
Using our target values:
- \(C_i = 100\%\)
- \(C_f = 0.4\%\)
$$ N = \ln\left(\frac{100}{0.4}\right) = \ln(250) \approx 5.52 $$
This means a minimum of \(5.52\) line volumes of \(\text{N}_2\) are required to hit the target. Standard practice applies a safety factor, often rounding up to \(N=7\) or even \(N=10\) volumes.
Estimation Example #
Estimate the \(\text{N}_2\) volume for a typical pipeline.
- Pipe Diameter: \(D = 8 \ \text{in} \approx 0.2032 \ \text{m}\)
- Pipe Length: \(L = 150 \ \text{m}\)
1. Find Line Volume (\(V_L\)): The pipe’s cross-sectional area \(A\) is: $$ A = \frac{\pi D^2}{4} = \frac{\pi \times (0.2032 \ \text{m})^2}{4} \approx 0.0324 \ \text{m}^2 $$ The total line volume \(V_L\) is: $$ V_L = A \times L = 0.0324 \ \text{m}^2 \times 150 \ \text{m} \approx 4.86 \ \text{m}^3 $$
2. Find Purge Volume (\(V_p\)): Using a safe \(N=10\) volume changes: $$ V_p = V_L \times N = 4.86 \ \text{m}^3 \times 10 = 48.6 \ \text{m}^3 $$
This \(48.6 \ \text{m}^3\) is the volume of \(\text{N}_2\)
required at the line’s operating pressure, \(P_{op}\). If \(P_{op} = 5 \ \text{barg}\) (\(\approx 6 \ \text{bar abs}\)), the equivalent volume at standard pressure (\(P_{std} \approx 1 \ \text{bar abs}\)) is found using the Ideal Gas Law (\(P_1V_1 = P_2V_2\)):
$$ V_{std} = \frac{V_p \times P_{op}}{P_{std}} = \frac{48.6 \ \text{m}^3 \times 6 \ \text{bar}}{1 \ \text{bar}} = 291.6 \ \text{m}^3 $$
This is a significant volume of nitrogen. Always confirm the final concentration (\(C_f < 0.4\%\)) using a calibrated \(\text{H}_2\) analyzer at the vent before stopping the purge.
Dilution Factor #
The dilution factor (DF) can be calculated as:
$$ \text{DF} = \frac{\text{Volume of N}_2}{\text{Volume of H}_2 + \text{Volume of N}_2} $$
Example Calculation #
Suppose a pipeline has a volume of 1000 m³ and contains 50 m³ of hydrogen. To ensure the hydrogen concentration is below the LEL, we need to add a sufficient volume of nitrogen.
- Initial Concentration of H₂:
$$ \text{Initial Concentration of H}_2 = \frac{50 \ \text{m}^3}{1000 \ \text{m}^3} \times 100% = 5% $$
- Required Volume of N₂:
To dilute the hydrogen concentration below the LEL of 4%, we need to add enough nitrogen to reduce the hydrogen concentration. Let’s denote the required volume of nitrogen as \(V_{\text{N}_2}\).
$$\text{Final Concentration of H}_2 = $$
$$\frac{50 \ \text{m}^3}{1000 \ \text{m}^3 + V_{\text{N}_2}} \times 100\% < 4\%$$
Solving for \(V_{\text{N}_2}\) :
$$ \frac{50}{1000 + V_{\text{N}_2}} < 0.04 $$
$$ 50 < 0.04 \times (1000 + V_{\text{N}_2}) $$
$$ 50 < 40 + 0.04 V_{\text{N}_2} $$
$$ 10 < 0.04 V_{\text{N}_2} $$
$$ V_{\text{N}_2} > \frac{10}{0.04} $$
$$ V_{\text{N}_2} > 250 \ \text{m}^3 $$
Therefore, at least 250 m³ of nitrogen is required to dilute the hydrogen concentration below the LEL.